South Dakota never closed down during the pandemic, and the freedom sustained for its citizens seems to be bearing positive results.
Here we go again…
As I said months ago, the call to apply a one-size-fits-all approach to #COVID19 is herd mentality; it's not leadership.
— Governor Kristi Noem (@govkristinoem) July 15, 2020
Republican Governor Kristy Noem noted on Fox and Friends that the state is seeing a decline in virus cases and, unlike most other states, defended its citizens’ freedom throughout the pandemic season.
Noem faced fierce criticism dearly the earlier stages of the quarantine season for keeping businesses open while encouraging her constituents to take personal responsibility for their health and the health of others.
South Dakota took a different path, a remarkable one: we gave our people their Freedom. pic.twitter.com/saedmqKXIR
— Governor Kristi Noem (@govkristinoem) July 17, 2020
“I think what we did here in South Dakota is really remarkable because we gave people their freedom,” she said. “We let the businesses stay open, we let people go to work, we told them to be smart, and we also asked them to be personally responsible. And, we’re seeing benefits of that each and every day in South Dakota.”
“We did, in fact, we according to the national experts, did everything wrong…We did what the people on the ground saw. We aggressively addressed those situations and came out better for it.”
Fox and Friends host Steve Doocy asked Noem if she had any advice for fellow state executives:
VIDEO OF THE DAY
Idiots Twerk On Ambulance After Shooting In Oakland, CA“Trust your people. Don’t lay down mandates that are going to hinder the ability that they need to really get through this difficult time…Trust them, give them the facts, let them make decisions that are right for their families,”
Noem is a devout Christian who publically shares her commitment to her faith. During her inauguration, Noem credited God for appointing her and told her audience how encouraging it is when they say that they’re praying for her.
“It is a great privilege and a solemn honor to serve as this state’s chief executive. It is one that do not take lightly because I believe that, as the Old Testament book of Daniel states, it is our God in heaven that puts leaders into place and it is He that removes them. As an elected leader, one of the most encouraging things that a citizen can do is to come up and say, “I’m praying for you.” Each and every time, I am encouraged and strengthened by those comments. So from this podium, on my first day in this high office, I ask for your prayers. Keep praying.”
Not really a success..
I think their geography helps them a lot, but their approach is not a success. SD has 889,000 people and 116 deaths. Ft Worth, Texas has 895,000 people and 164 deaths condensed into a large metropolitan area.
SD is about 1/3 the size of Texas in square miles.
SD has 11.5 people per square mile so, their person to person exposure is minimal.
Fort Worth, with the same population, has 2557 per square mile.
So, Fort Worth’s adherence to CDC policies resulted in about the same number of death results as SD’s wild west approach.
Fort Worth’s approach resulted in 222 times more successful.
SD had a better rate of death per thousand. 1 in 7663.79. FW had a 1 in 5457 death rate. Relatively same population. SD used no restrictions, but FW used CDC restrictions. I would say the better place to be is SD because there were likely more suicides, depression, anxiety and misery in FW. How you factor pop. density is questionable. There is no correlation to higher infection rate by population density. If you know of a study present it. The theory of higher infection rates being correlated to greater contact MAY be plausible but then for example SD did better even though they were free to congregate as normal. Schools, malls, restaurants and sports events stayed open. FW was more restricted and still had a higher death rate. There are many more factors that could change the trend. For instance ages and physical condition of those who perished. I am suggesting your supposition is not statistical based nor reasonable.
When you trust God you get good result it’s not about geographic location